Thursday, November 13, 2025

Was Israel’s response to Oct 7 disproportionate?

 

Accusations against Israel stem from emotive, unverified tolls and a shallow grasp of moral standards.


My latest article, in the Australian Jewish News, argues against the accusation that Israel's actions against Hamas are "disproportionate." I argue that such actions confuse proportionality (the measures needed to neutralise a threat) with symmetry (the number of casualties). I conclude that Israel's response has been justified and that responsibility for the casualties rests with Hamas-- the unjust aggressor.




Was Israel’s response to Oct 7 disproportionate?

  Was Israel’s response to Oct 7 disproportionate? Accusations against Israel stem from emotive, unverified tolls and a shallow grasp of mor...